2026 Midterms · U.S. House · Pennsylvania Safe
Pennsylvania — 5th District
Democratic
Mary Gay Scanlon
Incumbent
Republican
Nick Manganaro
Pennsylvania's 5th Congressional District 2026 general election features four-term Democratic incumbent Mary Gay Scanlon facing Republican challenger Nick Manganaro, a retired financial analyst and investor. Major race rating outlets—including Cook Political Report, Inside Elections, Sabato's Crystal Ball, and DDHQ/The Hill—rate the seat as Solid or Safe Democratic. The matchup largely hinges on contrasting visions for federal spending, economic regulation, immigration enforcement, and social safety net programs.
Economy and Spending
high salienceManganaro advocates capping federal spending and streamlining regulations to curb inflation, whereas Scanlon has repeatedly voted against Republican budget caps and tax credit repeals.
Mary Gay Scanlon
Opposes Republican spending cuts
Scanlon has opposed major Republican fiscal packages and reconciliation bills that included spending reductions or tax credit repeals, while supporting bipartisan debt-limit and tax reform agreements.
- Voted Nay on the 2025 reconciliation bill (H.R. 1) and the Limit, Save, Grow Act of 2023 (H.R. 2811)
- Voted Yea on the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 (H.R. 3746) and the Tax Relief for American Families and Workers Act of 2024 (H.R. 7024)
- Voted Nay on H.Con.Res. 14 establishing federal budget levels for fiscal years 2025 through 2034
Nick Manganaro
Supports spending cuts and deregulation
Manganaro identifies federal spending and national debt as primary drivers of inflation, advocating for strict fiscal discipline, deregulation, and private capital investment to boost business productivity and wages.
- Proposes holding the line on government spending to curb rising federal debt
- Advocates streamlining regulations to encourage private investments and increase corporate productivity
- Pledges to attract technology and manufacturing companies with well-paying jobs to PA-05
“Too much government spending is a major factor driving inflation.”
“The Federal debt is too darn high because members of Congress have a hard time making decisions and just saying no sometimes.”
Immigration and Border Security
high salienceScanlon favors comprehensive reform and has consistently voted against Republican border enforcement bills, while Manganaro advocates strict legal entry barriers and denying federal benefits to undocumented immigrants.
Mary Gay Scanlon
Supports comprehensive immigration reform
Scanlon lists immigration reform as a primary policy passion while consistently voting against conservative immigration enforcement and border security bills.
- Voted Nay on the Laken Riley Act (S. 5) and the Secure the Border Act of 2023 (H.R. 2)
- Voted Nay on H.R. 875 making driving while impaired grounds for deportation or inadmissibility
- Voted Nay on the resolution impeaching Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas (H.Res. 863)
“My top three priorities are voting rights, education, and criminal justice and immigration reform.”
Nick Manganaro
Opposes benefits for undocumented immigrants
Manganaro supports enforcing legal entry barriers and firmly opposes providing government benefits or assistance to undocumented immigrants entering the country.
- Pledges to protect legal barriers to entry into the United States
- Opposes providing tax-funded benefits to undocumented arrivals
“To protect this environment, we cannot afford to take down the existing legal barriers to entry into our nation and give undocumented arrivals generous benefits just for being here.”
Public Safety and Judicial Policy
low salienceScanlon focuses on criminal justice reform and voted against federal court injunction limits, whereas Manganaro broadly emphasizes maintaining a stable and just legal system.
Mary Gay Scanlon
Supports criminal justice reform
Scanlon champions criminal justice reform and child welfare policy, while voting against conservative measures restricting federal court authority.
- Voted Nay on NORRA of 2025 (H.R. 1526) limiting federal district court nationwide injunction authority
- Listed criminal justice reform and child welfare among her top passions
Nick Manganaro
Supports stable and just legal system
Manganaro highlights a stable and just legal system as an essential foundation for individual freedom and economic opportunity.
- Emphasizes the necessity of a stable and fair legal system to foster citizen opportunity
Voting Rights and Elections
medium salienceMary Gay Scanlon
Supports federal voting rights legislation
Scanlon considers voting rights a top legislative priority and opposes conservative voter identification requirements in federal elections.
- Voted Nay on the SAVE Act (H.R. 22) requiring documentary proof of citizenship to register for federal elections
- Identified voting rights as one of her top three priorities in her campaign profile
“I am especially passionate about issues that affect child welfare, gun violence prevention, immigration, and voting rights.”
Energy and Clean Infrastructure
medium salienceMary Gay Scanlon
Supports green energy investments
Scanlon advocates for green infrastructure investments and opposes expanding traditional fossil fuel extraction.
- Helped secure over $8 million in federal funding for electric vehicle charging infrastructure in Philadelphia
- Voted Nay on the Lower Energy Costs Act (H.R. 1) promoting domestic oil, gas, and coal production
Abortion and Reproductive Rights
medium salienceMary Gay Scanlon
Supports federal abortion access rights
Scanlon actively defends abortion access and fertility treatments, co-leading public campaigns against Republican restrictions on reproductive health.
- Co-led public efforts calling out opposition to abortion rights and IVF treatments
- Organized events in Delaware County opposing anti-choice policies
Social Safety Net
medium salienceScanlon voted to expand Social Security benefits and opposed SNAP work requirement expansions, whereas Manganaro opposes expanding safety net payouts or beneficiary lists.
Mary Gay Scanlon
Supports expanding social safety net
Scanlon supports strengthening Social Security and safety net protections, voting to reduce pension benefit offsets and opposing stricter safety net work requirements.
Nick Manganaro
Opposes expanding safety net benefits
Manganaro opposes expanding safety net payouts or beneficiary eligibility, arguing that social benefits should be strictly reserved for individuals who cannot otherwise support themselves.